What does your (winter) Tuesday look like?

Summer winter contrast

THE SATURDAY PROBLEM

France is very good at Saturdays. The market is open, café terraces are full, somebody is selling cheese under a striped awning, and the restaurant you discovered last night has somehow found you a table for lunch. The sun helps. So does the fact that you are on holiday. Under these conditions, an attractive town or village can feel almost impossibly easy to fall in love with.

The problem is that you are not buying the Saturday. If you are thinking about living in France for much of the year, the place also has to work on Tuesday, 17 November. That is a much less glamorous test, and a considerably more useful one. Tuesday tells you whether you actually like the life around the property, rather than simply the experience of visiting it.

START WITH THE ORDINARY DAY

Imagine waking up there in November. Where do you go for coffee? Can you walk, or are you immediately reaching for the car keys? Where do you buy food? Is the bakery still open? If you want to have dinner out, do you have a choice? If it rains for three days, what does your life look like then? If you need a doctor, where is the doctor?

These questions sound mundane because they are mundane. That is precisely why they matter. Most of life is made up of ordinary days, not exceptional ones. A place that works brilliantly during a two-week holiday may work very differently when you are there for eight months. The objective is not to remove the romance from moving to France. It is to make sure the romance survives contact with everyday life.

YOU ARE CHOOSING AN ECOSYSTEM

This is why I encourage buyers to stop thinking about a potential home as simply “a house in a village”. What you are really choosing is a practical ecosystem. The village may provide the bakery and café. The nearby town may provide the supermarket, doctors and restaurants. The hospital may be 35 minutes away, the TGV station 50 minutes, and the airport an hour and fifteen.

Taken together, these places form the geography of your real life. A tiny village five minutes from a lively town may be far more practical than a larger village half an hour from everything. Equally, a rural house can work perfectly if isolation is genuinely what you want. There is no correct ecosystem. There is only the one that fits the life you are trying to create.

TEST THE JOURNEYS YOU WILL ACTUALLY MAKE

Maps are useful, but they can create false confidence. Twenty kilometres can mean an easy fifteen-minute drive or forty minutes of bends, villages, roundabouts and the occasional tractor. “Close to Montpellier” or “near Avignon” tells you much less than knowing how long you will actually spend reaching the places you expect to use.

So test the journeys. Drive to the supermarket. Find the hospital. Go to the railway station. If the airport matters, drive there too. If you imagine walking into town for dinner, actually walk the route. A house can be technically close to a village centre while the only route involves a busy road with no pavement. Everyday geography is often discovered with your feet and your car, not on Google Maps.

DO BORING THINGS ON PURPOSE

When you visit an area seriously, try not to organise the trip entirely around beautiful things. Go to the supermarket. Buy petrol. Find the pharmacy. Park in the town centre. Work out where you would walk the dog. If you expect to cycle, bring or rent a bicycle. Visit the larger town you would probably use for things the village cannot provide.

It may be the least glamorous property advice you receive, but these activities reveal how a place functions. They also slow you down. Instead of moving from estate agent to house to restaurant to hotel, you begin experiencing the area as someone who lives there. Sometimes a place becomes more attractive when you do this. Sometimes the opposite happens. Both outcomes are useful.

SEE THE PLACE WHEN IT IS NOT PERFORMING

Tourism can make small French towns extraordinarily lively. That is often a strength. Visitors support restaurants, shops, markets and cultural events that might otherwise disappear. But seasonal life can also distort your impression. A village with six restaurants in August and one open on a Tuesday in February is offering two very different versions of itself.

That does not automatically make it unsuitable. Perhaps you want peace in winter. Perhaps you will only use the property for four months each year. But if you plan to live there permanently, February counts. So ask people what winter is like. Return outside the main season if you can. Find out whether “quiet” means pleasantly calm or effectively closed.

THINK ABOUT THE PEOPLE WHO WILL COME TO YOU

Your French location does not only need to work for you. If children, grandchildren, friends or relatives are part of the life you imagine, think about their journeys too. A remote house may feel wonderfully peaceful after you arrive by car for three weeks. It may feel rather different to somebody arriving after two flights, a train journey and another ninety minutes on the road.

You do not need to organise your entire life around visitors. But if regular visits are part of the plan, accessibility belongs in the equation. The same applies to your own future. Driving everywhere may feel effortless at 58. At 75, you may value a nearby town, healthcare, shops, taxis or simply being able to walk somewhere considerably more.

TEST THE PLACE BEFORE THE PROPERTY

This is ultimately the point. Before asking whether you could live in a particular house, ask whether you could live here. Stay locally. Wake up there. Drive the roads. Have coffee. Go out at night. Talk to residents. Compare the place against the things you said mattered to you before the property search started influencing your judgement.

There will always be another beautiful house in France. The harder task is finding the place in which your ordinary life works naturally. Once you know that, the property search becomes much more disciplined. You are no longer trying to persuade yourself that a house justifies the location. You are looking for a house inside an ecosystem you have already chosen.

THE HOUSE STILL MATTERS

None of this means the house is unimportant. It matters enormously. You should love it, or at least be able to see clearly how it can become something you love. But a beautiful house in the wrong place forces you to compromise every day. A very good house in exactly the right ecosystem can become the perfect house remarkably quickly.

So when you next explore somewhere in France, enjoy the sunny Saturday. Go to the market. Have the long lunch. Notice the light and the stone walls and all the reasons you wanted France in the first place. Then come back to the more revealing question: what does your Tuesday in November look like here? That is often where the real decision begins.

Get the free guide